Hadzabe tribespeople

Doomsday Machine

Forces of nature

The Hadzabe are an African tribe. They hardly trade, and they don’t use money. They can survive an apocalypse. But can you? Trade and money have turned us into cogs in a system. Many of us can’t survive without what some might call ‘The System’, the catch-all term for large-scale human organisation centred on states and markets. We came to depend on the market and the state rather than ourselves, our family and our community. We have exchanged resilience for convenience, and for a reason. We specialise to compete. As the organisations we take part in become more competitive, we turn into more inept individuals. We survive on performing a trick, our job, but we can’t survive without markets and governments. People in the past had a wider variety of skills than doing their jobs and going to shops. When things fall apart, those who don’t trade are best positioned to survive. In other words, trade will eventually kill us all.

The forces of nature, competition and cooperation made it happen. We cooperate to compete, which pushes us to work within complex organisations to keep up with other complex organisations. That perspective provides an illuminating insight. Plants and animals cooperate and compete for resources. Cooperation and competition are everywhere. Cooperation increases the available resources. For example, plants generate the oxygen animals need, while animals produce the carbon dioxide plants need. And rhinos attract ticks and flies that the red-billed oxpecker lives off, so the rhino benefits from the bird while the bird benefits from the rhino. Still, the available resources are limited, so there is room for only one tree in a particular spot. And so there is competition as well, a struggle for life.

Plants and animals take advantage of opportunities in their environment through both competition and cooperation. Plants and animals have a blueprint, their genes, that define their properties, so that a chestnut can become a chestnut tree, and an ovum and a sperm can generate a new aardvark. Genes have the peculiar urge to make copies of themselves. It is why we exist and the basis of our will to live. The biological purpose of plants and animals, including humans, is to spread their genes. That is all there is to it, nothing more. The copying process is prone to errors, resulting in variation within species.

Some of these changes make individual plants and animals better adapted to their environment, increasing their chances of survival and reproduction, leading to a rising number of individuals with these genes and features. Environments allow for species to coexist, most notably when they don’t compete for the same resources. This is why ants and monkeys can live in the same area. The balance in nature is precarious and temporary, so there is no real balance. It constantly shifts, as changes in the environment harm and favour particular individuals and species in the struggle for life.

Meet our closest relatives

The chimpanzees are our closest kin. Studying these apes provides us with some insights into our nature. Chimpanzees live in small troops of a few dozen individuals. They form friendships, work with reliable group members, and avoid unreliable ones. Chimpanzees have rules, may cheat on them, and may feel guilty when they do. Within the group, the members have ranks. When there is food available, the highest-status animals eat first. Ranks and rules define who does what and who gets what. They regulate the competition and misunderstandings within the troop, reducing conflicts and enabling its members to collaborate more effectively.

Like human leaders, chimpanzee alpha males acquire their status by building coalitions and gaining support. Others show their submission to the alpha male. Like a government, the alpha male strives to maintain social harmony within his group. He takes sought-after pieces of food like a government collects taxes. Within a chimpanzee band, there are subgroups and coalitions. There are close friendships and more distant relationships. They unite as a single fighting force in the event of an external threat.

Coalition members in a chimpanzee band build and maintain close ties through intimate daily contact, such as hugging, kissing, and doing favours for each other. For the band to function effectively, its members must be aware of what others will do in critical situations. For that, they need to know each other through personal experiences. Unlike humans, chimpanzees have no language to share social information. That limits the size of the group in which chimpanzees can live and work together to about thirty individuals.

Chimpanzees also commit group violence. Like humans, they are among the species that commit genocide on their congeners. Humans and chimpanzees are not alone in this. Chickens are known to fight racial wars when they face a lack of food. Groups of chickens may start killing those with different colours from their own. And so, racism could be a natural behaviour caused by competition between genes.

The human advantage

Humans have become the dominant species on Earth. We can collaborate flexibly in large numbers. We have mastered fire, which enhances our power and allows us to eat foods we couldn’t otherwise. It allowed us to become the top predator. We use tools and clothing, allowing us to do things other animals can’t and live in inhospitable environments. Compared to other animals, humans employ a rich language. That enables us to express countless meanings and describe situations in precise terms.

We pass on social information, such as who is fit for a particular job. We get information about others in our group without needing personal experience. If someone cheats, you don’t need to learn it the hard way, as chimpanzees must. Someone can tell you. That allows us to cooperate more effectively. Most human communication is social information or gossip. We need the group to survive, so we must understand what is happening within it and the decisions it needs to make.

Human politics is about cooperating and competing. We must agree on what we should do as a group and on how we divide the spoils of our cooperation. Within the group, we may compete to cooperate. Leadership contests benefit the group when the outcome is better leadership. That isn’t always the case, while infighting can weaken the group. We also cooperate to compete. We organise ourselves in groups to compete with other groups, such as defeating them in warfare.

Early humans lived in gangs of up to 150 individuals. The number of individuals with whom we can closely collaborate is one of our natural limitations. We overcame the limits of our natural group size by cooperating through shared imaginings, such as religions, laws, money, and nation-states. That competitive advantage over other species allowed us to take over this planet and become the ‘killer bug’ that has upended nature and has terminated more species than any other species or natural disasters.

Unlike other animals and plants that adapt to their environment, we alter our environment to make it suit us. We have created societies and civilisations and have become immensely powerful collectives capable of competing with other collectives. However, our civilisations also shield us from the forces of nature, turning us into weak individuals. We have become integrated into the system, and many of us won’t survive its collapse. Competition drives this process, most notably trade, and even more than warfare.

We imagine corporations, laws, money, and nation-states. We believe a law exists, and that is why the law works. It is also why religion works. These shared imaginations allow us to cooperate on any scale for any purpose. We are programmable, with our brains serving as the hardware and our imaginations serving as the software. And we can change the software overnight. During the French Revolution, the French stopped believing in the divine right of kings overnight and began to envision popular sovereignty.

Our urges and inner motivations relate to these forces of nature. We imagine things because that helps us win the competition. We imagine our realities because we are creatures who cooperate based on stories. And so, our environment becomes increasingly unnatural. Civilisation shields us from the forces of nature, most notably, the struggle for survival, so that the inept can survive and procreate. Once the story falls apart, society breaks down, and the forces of nature reassert themselves.

Organising to compete

The forces of competition and population density drove humans to organise. Just as there is competition between species in nature, there is also competition between human groups. Groups that succeeded in adapting to new circumstances survived, whereas those that did not perished. We are rule-following animals. It allowed us to cooperate on a larger scale using political institutions that embody the rules of our community or society.

The stories, norms, values and agreements people within a group share form their culture. Cultural values can confer an advantage on one group relative to others. Individualism and the replacement of Christian values with capitalist ones helped Europeans to organise themselves more flexibly and make their conquests profitable, thereby sustaining their expansion. Their culture helped Europeans to conquer the world.

Humans design political institutions, whereas genetic mutations arise by chance. In both cases, competition determines which designs survive and become copied. In general, under the pressure of competition, which often took the form of warfare, human organisation advanced from bands to tribes to feudalism to states. This explanation is simplistic and flawed. Still, overall, such a trend towards more advanced organisation occurred.

Hunter-gatherers lived in family groups of a few dozen individuals. They had few violent conflicts. They had no property, and population density was low. They could move on if a stronger band invaded their territory. Small groups were egalitarian. They had no permanent leader or hierarchy and decided on leadership based on group consensus.

The Agricultural Revolution changed that. Farming allowed more people to survive. Farmers invested heavily in their cattle and crops, so agricultural societies required property rights and defence. Agriculture promoted the transition from bands to tribes. Population density increased, leading to more frequent violent conflicts. Tribes are much larger than bands and can muster more men for war, so tribes replaced bands.

Tribes were usually egalitarian, but often a separate warrior caste emerged. The most basic permanent political organisation was the lord and his armed vassals, known as feudalism. The lord and his vassals exchange favours. The loyalty of the vassals is crucial, and politics is about these loyalties and betrayals. Tribalism centres around kinship, but also includes feudalist, personal relationships of mutual reciprocity and personal ties.

States

States wield more power than tribes because they can compel cooperation, whereas tribes rely on voluntary arrangements. As population density increased and people lived closer together, the need to resolve conflicts also grew, so some states provided justice services. Leaders, with their family and friends, led these states. They worked with personal, feudal relationships, thus making deals and returning favours. And so, the transition from tribes to feudalism to states is not a straightforward process.

The first modern, rationally organised states with professional bureaucracies based on merit rather than personal relationships and favours appeared in China. The reason was a centuries-long, cutthroat competition in warfare on an unprecedented scale, with states fielding armies of up to 500,000 men, during the Warring States Era. Fielding these armies required professional tax collection, detailed records of people and their possessions, and provisioning them in the field.

Once the state of Qin emerged victorious by 200 BC, China became unified, and the competition between the states ended, and China’s modernisation ground to a halt. Even so, China adhered to modern bureaucratic principles and remained the most modern state for 2,000 years, enabling its rulers to govern a vast empire. States remained the most competitive organisational form until Europeans invented capitalism and corporations, which introduced a radically new dynamic of permanent change driven by competition.

Capitalism and corporations


In the Middle Ages, China had a strong centralised state and was ahead of the rest of the world, yet Europe came out on top. The Chinese government prevented the merchants from becoming the dominant force in society. In the Middle Ages, Western Europe lacked strong states and exhibited greater individualism, allowing capitalism to emerge there gradually. That took centuries and was the outcome of factors shaping Western European culture and their interactions in a historical process in which competition played a defining role. The rise of merchants and, later, corporations brought a new economic dynamic and wealth. Corporations are legal entities serving a specific purpose. Invented in Roman times, they became a competitive advantage in business ventures.

Corporations limited the risks for entrepreneurs and investors and allowed for the raising of more capital. From the Middle Ages onward, Europeans established commercial corporations with shares and stock markets, such as the Dutch East India Company (VOC). The advent of corporations triggered a new phase in the competitive cycle, further increasing efficiency by specialising in specific tasks. The Europeans combined their inquisitiveness with entrepreneurship, so the profit motive eventually began to drive innovation.

The new dynamic intensified competition and innovation, causing permanent economic growth and disruptive change, a process economists call creative destruction. Capitalism increases available resources via cooperation or the division of labour, but competition is the driving force. It favours economies of scale. For instance, you see supermarket chains replacing smaller grocery stores. It is also why we have weapons of mass destruction and industrial warfare. The competition will eventually ruin us all.

At present, East Asian countries such as China appear to have the most competitive socio-economic model. It helps that the people there are less individualistic. The Chinese also have the longest tradition of rationally organised government. Yet, it will not end well for them either. Artificial intelligence will soon outcompete humans. It will become the ‘killer bug’ that terminates humanity. We can’t keep up with artificial intelligence. And so, the future doesn’t need us. We aren’t sufficiently efficient, creative and innovative. Competition is our doomsday machine. Whoever wins the race will be dead. If humankind is to survive, competition, insofar as we allow it, should serve cooperation. If we don’t get a grip on the competition, we are doomed.

Latest revision: 7 November 2026

Featured image: Hadzabe tribespeople. Calvin pro7. Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 4.0.

State of Human Nature

Social animals

In philosophy, the state of nature is about human nature and our natural way of life. We are social animals who operate in groups. What makes us unique is that we can collaborate flexibly on any scale. We employ language and shared imaginations like corporations, nation-states, money and religions. They help us collaborate. In this way, we created an imaginary world, civilisation. We can program ourselves to a significant degree and have different cultures. So, what is our natural way of living? That is hard to tell, but we can say a few things.

We help our family and friends but can also cooperate with strangers. It is not something we learn. It is natural human behaviour. Other social animals also do it, including chimpanzees, our closest relatives. Chimpanzees live in small troops of a few dozen individuals. Like us, they have close friendships, work together with reliable congeners and avoid unreliable ones. They have social rules, may cheat and probably can feel guilty. Like human males, chimpanzee males can be violent and kill each other.

Like human leaders, chimpanzee alpha males acquire their status by building coalitions and gaining support. Others show their submission to the alpha male. He strives to maintain social harmony within his troop, like a king maintaining peaceful relations between his subjects. He takes coveted pieces of food like the government takes taxes. Alpha males gain their position by building a coalition of supporters. Usually, a chimpanzee band has several alliances.

Coalition members in a chimpanzee band build and maintain their ties through intimate daily contact. They hug, touch, kiss, groom and take fleas from each other’s furs. Like humans, they do each other mutual favours. The coalitions in a chimpanzee band have good relations to protect themselves against outside enemies. Within the group, there are friendships and more distant, colder relationships.

There is a limit to the size of a group of chimpanzees. To function as a chimpanzee band, all members must know each other intimately. They must remember how others acted in the past to guess what they will do. Unlike humans, they have no language to share social information. Humans gossip to share information about others. Thus, we can learn someone is unreliable without being cheated upon ourselves. That allows us to collaborate in more sophisticated ways in larger groups.

Chimpanzee groups with more than a few dozen individuals are unstable. Its members do not know each other well enough to establish a hierarchy. Separate groups of chimpanzees seldom cooperate and compete for territory and food. There have been cases of prolonged warfare between groups of chimpanzees, including a few instances of genocide. Early humans lived similar lives but could live in larger and more stable bands of up to 150 individuals. The size of a group with which we can closely cooperate is one of our natural limits. We have overcome that limit with shared imaginations, which might be unnatural and a source of many troubles we have today.

Shared imaginations

We think in terms of cause and effect. We believe clouds cause rainfall. Our imagination also allows us to attribute causes to imaginary things. If the harvest fails, we can think the gods are angry. To deal with that, we can start a ritual like sacrificing a goat in the planting season to please the gods. Rituals also have another role. They bond a community and can outlive the beliefs that created them and lose their meaning. Many atheists still celebrate Christmas and think of eating turkey rather than the birth of Jesus.

Large groups face difficulties acting as a collective. Distinguishing between the contributions of individual members becomes challenging, so cheating and opportunistic behaviour are more common. Money, states, and belief systems like religions and ideologies help us deal with that. Money can keep track of our contributions and usages. States enforce cooperation. Religions and ideologies help us collaborate, for instance, by promising rewards in the afterlife or telling inspiring tales of worker solidarity.

For that, we share our imaginations. We imagine laws, money, property, corporations and nation-states. We think a euro banknote has value, even though it is just a piece of paper. And that is why we can use it for payment. If we believe the banknote is worthless, we cannot accept it or use it for payment. We imagine a law exists and, therefore, it works. Without these shared imaginations, our societies would stop functioning. Our cooperation also requires an inspiring story like a myth about the founders, a religion or an ideology.

Stories are the basis of our large-scale cooperation. We change how we cooperate and build societies by changing the stories. In 1789, the French population switched from the story of the divine right of kings to the sovereignty of the people. That changed the organisation of French society from feudal to modern, an advantage that Napoleon could subsequently exploit on the battlefield. Intelligent animals like monkeys can learn new behaviour but cannot change their organisation because they lack the stories to do so.

Norms and values

We invent rules and follow them. That is also in our nature. The rules differ per group, but all groups have rules. Norms are shared rules and expectations about the behaviour in a group or society. They maintain the social order, define cultural values, and shape social interactions. Norms can be laws, folkways, mores, taboos. Values are beliefs about what is important to us and society. Values can be honesty, respect, fairness and kindness. Norms and values thus reflect our rules.

Our rule-following behaviour is ingrained in our nature and comes with emotions like anger, shame and pride. If we have rules, we can spend less time negotiating about who does what and who gets what. It allows us to cooperate more efficiently and effectively. It also limits our freedom. We cling to our norms and values. Rules make societies stable. But they cause trouble if they have outlived their usefulness and block much-needed change.

Most of our communication is gossip. We need the group to survive. To survive, we must understand what is happening in our group. We talk about other people in our group, for instance, who is cheating or breaking agreements and what we should do about it. Groups enforce their rules by pressuring or ostracising those who do not conform to them. Being evicted from your group is particularly traumatic as it can lead to death.

Our inclination to attach value to mental models and theories promotes social stability. It also makes societies conservative regarding ideas and rules. Rules and institutions emerged to meet a specific challenge and become a burden once they have outlived their usefulness. Social change is often not a process of small steps but of long periods of standstill alternated with sudden dramatic changes.

Violence is often crucial for change. The fear of violent death can motivate us to do things we would not do out of self-interest alone. Those who benefit from the current arrangement hold off changes, so violence or the threat of violence can end the stalemate. That happened in the French Revolution. The human desire for recognition means politics is seldom about mere self-interest. We also judge leaders and the rules in society with our norms and values.

The struggle for recognition

Societies require individual members to play particular roles. Each role has a status and norms based on the values and beliefs of the culture of that society. Socialisation is learning your role in society and the norms and values that come with it. Groups of humans, including societies, have social hierarchies with statuses attached to the roles people play. In organised societies, status differences are more pronounced than in small groups. That is called stratification.

An individual or a group can recognise another person’s or group’s status, including this person’s or group’s beliefs and customs. The struggle for recognition differs from the struggle for material goods. All parties can gain from an economic transaction. You can exchange your fish for bread if you want bread more if someone else has bread and desires fish. But humans imagine social hierarchies. The recognition of one person, group or nation thus comes at the expense of others.

We aspire to social status, and some compete for leadership. Chimpanzee males compete for the status of the alpha male but also cooperate to defeat an enemy. We not only desire recognition for ourselves. We also seek respect for our beliefs and the groups we belong to. Much of our struggle concerns respect for groups such as women, ethnic minorities and homosexuals. There is an economic aspect, such as equal pay for women, but it is primarily about recognition. Pay is also a token of respect.

You cannot enforce recognition. Others must feel you deserve it. Leadership comes from a group acknowledging that a specific person has exceptional courage or wisdom or is impartial in conflicts and a desire from a community to have a leader. Once a society develops, we transfer our recognition to political institutions like parliaments and courts rather than individual leaders. In both cases, the political order requires legitimacy to make people accept the order and adhere to the rules.

Changing our environment

We change our environment. So, if we have a natural environment, we can make it unnatural. The first humans lived as hunter-gatherers in small groups of a few dozen individuals. Everyone in the group knew each other. If that is our natural way of living, city life would be unnatural. Our mental makeup emerged from evolution, so living in large cities could produce psychological problems like stress and alienation. The biblical vision of the state of nature is Eden, where people lived in harmony with nature.

But what does that mean? In the last 400,000 years, humans have become the top predators. That had enormous consequences for what we can eat and do. And it had psychological and social effects. Humans did not evolve but suddenly rose to their new position. Many historical calamities and things about how humans behave towards others and the environment, from the deadly wars to how people treat the ecosystem around them, result from this fast change that our evolution could not match.

Humans like Neanderthals, and later the modern humans, Homo Sapiens, began using fire. It gave them light, warmth, and an effective weapon against dangerous animals like lions and bears. That changed the balance of power between the animal species. The humans came out on top. Humans also used fire to change their environment. They started burning down forests and collected dead animals cooked in the fire to eat them. And cooking allowed them to eat more sorts of food.

The Agricultural Revolution was another dramatic change in human lifestyle. To feed more people, humans began to grow crops and herd animals. With agriculture, more people could survive, but it created new problems. Hunter-gatherers could move on in the case of conflict, but farmers had to protect their land and cattle against thieves and invaders. And so there were more intense conflicts, and people began to organise themselves for larger-scale wars in tribes and states.

Latest revision: 23 December 2023

Featured image: cover of The Origins of Political Order

From: The Origins of Political Order: From Prehuman Times to the French Revolution of Francis Fukuyama.